Lee County, FL
Pine Island
Pine Island — including Matlacha, Bokeelia, and St. James City — is Old Florida at its most authentic: a working waterfront and fishing community with no sand beaches (it's ringed by mangroves), the colorful artist village of Matlacha, and a distinctly slower pace.
The vibe
Pine Island trades resort polish for character — fishing, boating, art galleries in Matlacha, and waterfront cottages. It appeals to buyers who want authentic, quiet, water-oriented Florida living away from the crowds.
What's nearby
- Matlacha
- Bokeelia
- St. James City
- Pine Island Sound
What you'll find here
- Waterfront & canal homes
- Old-Florida cottages
- Stilt homes
Who it's for
Boaters, anglers, and buyers who want authentic, laid-back Old-Florida waterfront over resort living.
Frequently asked questions
- Does Pine Island have beaches?
- Pine Island is ringed by mangroves rather than sand beaches — its draw is the working waterfront, fishing, boating, and the Old-Florida character of Matlacha, Bokeelia, and St. James City rather than beachfront.
Thinking about Pine Island?
Talk to a full-time local Southwest Florida specialist — The Gulf Coast Team at Royal Shell Real Estate.